While the iliad is an epic sweeping war story, it can get a bit repetitive, with all the battles and the killings and the rosyfingered dawns the most interesting bit to me was how all of the tough noble warrior men in the story were, at various points, weeping masses of untempered emotion. The iliad is an ancient greek epic poem in dactylic hexameter, traditionally attributed to homer. Similarities and differences in the aeneid and the odyssey. So it might be because of sentimental reasons that i prefer the odyssey, but i also prefer the different adventures and characters in the odyssey over the iliad. Another obvious difference is the absence of godly intercession of the grecian gods in the movie. In the text, the greeks, history, culture and society, authors morris and powell compare and contrast the iliad and the odyssey as such, the remarkable odysseyhas a tripartite plot, but moves more in spirals than in a straight line. Also attributed to homer, the odyssey is a greek epic poem written as a sequel to the iliad. And with formulaic language stripped away, it is the characters and their.
They are both epic poems believed to have been written by homer. I just need good similarities and differences between the two and ill find where they are in the book. Set during the trojan war, the tenyear siege of the city of troy ilium by a coalition of greek states, it tells of the battles and events during the weeks of a quarrel between king agamemnon and the warrior achilles. Find all the books, read about the author, and more. The iliad and odyssey are composed in a long dactylic line tumpetytumpetytum thats poorly suited to the natural rhythms of.
What are the difference between the iliad and the odyssey. Homers iliad and ovids metamorphoses provide a wealth of insight into greek literature and myth in antiquity. Examine the similarities and the differences between homers iliad and odyssey the iliad and the odyssey are ancient greek epic poems, traditionally ascribed to homer. What is the link between the iliad and the odyssey answers. When writing the aeneid, virgil or vergil drew from his studies on the homeric epics of the iliad and the odyssey to help him create a national epic poem for the roman people. How do homers the iliad and odyssey compare and contrast.
The iliad describes the events of the trojan war, namely a few weeks of the last year of the war. Major differences between the homers iliad and the film troy. Describes only some 50 days of the war, although youll get the feeling yo. Both the film and the poem have the same overall plots, such as the siege of troy by the greeks, the feud between the. Centred on the trojan war, these two ancient greek epic poems are world renowned not only for the engaging dialogue with which they present turn of events but also for the beauty with which it is unfolded. Homers name can be translated from a word that means blind, but the vivid imagery of the iliad and the odyssey suggest that the author of the poems must have had sight at some point in his life. The iliad and the odyssey are two of the key works of western. Examine the similarities and the differences between homers iliad and. Dicuss similarities and differences between homers iliad. Whereas the iliad describes a man at odds with his society, a man apart, the odyssey describes a man. The duel between paris and menelaus is interrupted by aphrodite, who takes paris back into the city walls. Difference between iliad and odyssey compare the difference. The odyssey and the penelopiads storyline are both based off the same social context as homer recorded the epic poem during homeric society when he was alive however when the story was composed the literary context is completely different in comparison to atwood, as atwood wrote her novella the penelopiad, in the 21st century and homer recorded the epic poem during 8th c bce.
Are the iliad and the odyssey different or similar. The iliad is a fictional war poem about the attainment of enduring glory through strength, bravery, and cunningthat is, proficiency in slaughterbut its sequel, the odyssey, makes a distinction between glory fame and honor adherence to what is right or to a conventional standard of conduct and promotes honor above glory as the right code of conduct. Difference of troy movie and iliad freebooksummary. Difference between the iliad and odysseus 868 words. Parallels between virgils aeneid and homers iliad and odyssey. This distinction is important to understanding the iliad. The language of the iliad and the odyssey suggest that homer came from the western coast of the modern nation of turkey. In 1995, director mario camerini released a film adaptation of homers epic.
This essential similarity between the two epics provides ground for comparison. What i mean by this is that while both books contain the same gods and much of the same attitude and actions when it comes to mythology, they are constructed in very different ways. Robert fitzgerald university press 1974 has been retold in many other forms, the most recent being the blockbuster film troy 2004, wolfgang peterson. The iliad and the odyssey by homer bookworm history. Dicuss similarities and differences between homers iliad and the movie troy essay sample.
The odyssey by homer and the penelopiad by margaret atwood. Descent to the underworld in the aeneid and the odyssey i chose to compare the odyssey written by the greek poet homer and the aeneid by the roman poet virgil. The reason of these differences in the film troy and the iliad are to convenience of the director and for. It is very apparent that the film troy, directed by wolfgang peterson, has been heavily influenced by the epic poem, the iliad, a work commonly credited to the ancient greek poet homer. The iliad is about the siege of troy during the trojan war, and the odyssey is the story of the soldiers journey home from troy. Secondly, i am sharing this with the literary blog hop at the blue bookcase. Both stories take place over the course of ten years and many of the characters are alike but take different names depending on which story youre reading. The odyssey is a fundamental work in the modern western canon, being the oldest extant piece of western literature, second to the iliad. Whats the difference between iliad and the odyssey. The iliad the wrath of achilles not only begins the oldest piece of western literature, but is also its premise.
A version of homer that dares to match him line for line. Rutherford, from the iliad to the odyssey, in oxford readings in homers iliad, oxford university press, 2001, pp. The differences of the odyssey by homers the odyssey. On warriors, poets, and what eternal glory really comes down to the iliad and the odyssey by homer big news, folks. Differences between the odyssey and the odyssey 1209. Start studying similarities between the iliad and the odyssey. It is, in part, a sequel to the iliad, the other homeric epic. Similarities between the iliad and the odyssey flashcards. The iliad and the odyssey are attributed to the poet homer and are the earliest surviving works of western literature. The role of the gods in the affairs of humanity is much greater in the iliad then in the odyssey. Aphrodite are scattered throughout the book, however, so the views between the iliad and the odyssey are not exactly diametrically opposed. Join achilles at the gates of troy as he slays hector to avenge the death of patroclus. The odyssey focuses on odysseus, king of ithaca, and his.
Virgil used several characteristics associated with epic poetry, more specifically homer s epics, including the use of hexameter verse, book division, lists of genealogies and underlying themes to draw parallels. When it comes to epic poetry, the iliad and the odyssey are the two names that spring to mind. Here is a story of love and war, hope and despair, and honor and. The iliad and odyssey, homer the iliad is an ancient greek epic poem in dactylic hexameter, traditionally attributed to homer.
While the iliad is focused on the war, battles, and fights, the odyssey is a tale about adventures, trials, and mythological creatures. The opinion that the book division of the iliad and the odyssey was imposed upon the. Aristotle said that the iliad was a poem in which things happened to people, while the odyssey was a poem of character. Thanks to anyone who answers, im not asking for people to do my paper for me i just need help with the differences. We still say they were written by the blind poet homer, but thats as much.
The iliad is an epic poem recounting the final year of the trojan war between troy and the greek army. As the gods where what made the 10 twelvemonth war come to go through in the first topographic point doing the iliad an heroic conflict of volitions. Both hephaestus, in homers iliad, and odysseus, in homers the odyssey, set out to portray the cultures that they saw, yet the cultures and societies varied greatly, from hephaestus illustrating the highly developed societies of the greek and their culture. Basically i need to develop a argument between the the two that ties in with this.
As a result of these differences, both stories end up sending contrasting messages about life in general. Author says a whole culturenot a single homerwrote iliad, odyssey. All english translators of homer face a basic problem. Varying cultural structures in homers the illiad and the odyssey 1008 words 5 pages. The movie hasnt shown any close relationships between the greeks and trojans and their gods and goddesses. I am writing an essay on the similarities and differences between the iliad and the odyssey. Insomnia relief fall asleep fast the blue forest binaural beats sleep music duration. This is roughly about the time moses led the israelites from egypt through the time david ruled a united jewish nation.
I was read the odyssey when i was a kid and i read the iliad by myself when i was older. In the iliad, homer emphasizes the role of the gods. The odyssey, on the other hand deals mostly with odysseus. The war lasted 10 years though the iliad summarizes them and mainly tells of the last year. Menelaus survives the war and later appears in the odyssey. The iliad demonstrates the close interactions between the gods and goddesses and their followers.
Both the film and the poem have the same overall plots, such as the siege of troy by the greeks. The most apparent difference troy has from the iliad is its absence of olympian gods, the greek pantheon of deities who reside on mount olympus. Both books share a lot in common in terms of mythology but not much in common in terms of literature. Although both works are credited to homer, the iliad and the odyssey provide two remarkably different views on the nature of the olympian gods, their relationship to humanity, and the general lot of mortals throughout their all too brief lives. The epics written by homer are all about love, compassion, patience, suffering and sacrificing. Homer s iliad and ovids metamorphoses provide a wealth of insight into greek literature and myth in antiquity. Comparison between iliad and odyssey essay 1070 words. The odyssey makes reference at a number of points to the characters and events of the iliad, most notably to the death of achilles. The most significant difference between the two poems, which entails other dissimilarities, is their overall theme and idea. A ancient greek vase depicting ajax preparing to commit suicide the reason for these differences between the iliad and the film troy are nearly 100% economic as when looking at each individual example of the differences all of them are either due to lowering expensescomplexity of making the film troy i. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. However, the stories are probably older than homer. Find the difference between the two iliad and odyssey. The odyssey is an epic poem written by homer in ancient greece, mostly likely close to the end of the 8th century bc.
I will focus my interest on book 11 of the odyssey and book 6 of the aeneid, since that is when both of the main characters make an educational visit to the underworld. Menelaus is about to kill paris when hector intervenes and kills menelaus. The iliad and the odyssey cover two different time periods. The iliad is paired with something of a sequel, the odyssey, also attributed to homer. The iliad and the odyssey are two of the greatest works of western literature. The odyssey is its sequel yet it focuses on one group of men, and odysseus specifically rather. Takes place in a very specific place, mainly the beach of troy and the city itself. Composed sometime around the eighth century bc, the ancient greek poems has since been translated into many languages and serves as an important source of information on ancient greek culture and mythology. The second half of the aeneid, books vi through xii, follow similarly to what.
Homer is known for being the author of both stories. The iliad and the odyssey analysis essay blog essayshark. Virgil used several characteristics associated with epic poetry, more specifically homers epics, including the use of hexameter verse, book division, lists of genealogies and underlying themes to draw parallels. What is the difference between the iliad and the odyssey. When and how were the iliad and theodyssey divided into songs. Difference between gilgamesh and the iliad free essays. Achilles avenges hector for killing patroclus and aneus kills pallas in order to. War, death, loss and exile were common for the people who listened to these poems, and homer wrote what they felt. In the iliad, the olympians are constantly meddling in the conflict between the greeks and the trojans. Parallels between virgils aeneid and homers iliad and. Difference between iliad and odyssey the iliad is set during the time of the ten year old trojan war. The odyssey commentary was also written by scholars with different atti. Bicameral mind, which posits that until about the time described in the iliad, humans had a far different mentality from present day humans. Homer uses the exacerbated form of conflict, war as the setting for his the iliad, and john milton makes it explicit through the clash between god and satan.
1321 1350 872 9 1475 790 1507 1146 575 565 690 1176 1263 901 98 94 390 1393 1514 1310 503 1388 1437 802 1410 64 1089 945 307 878 1348 1011